What role has Martha Stewart’s image played in the insider trading scandal? 2. Will Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia survive if Martha Stewart were to leave the company? In order to survive, what...

1 answer below »
What role has Martha Stewart’s image played in the insider trading scandal? 2. Will Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia survive if Martha Stewart were to leave the company? In order to survive, what changes will need to be made at the company? 3. How has Martha Stewart’s conviction impacted the business environment today?


Document Preview:

Daniels Fund Ethics Initiative University of New Mexico http://danielsethics.mgt.unm.edu Martha Stewart’s Insider Trading Scandal INTRODUCTION Martha Stewart is one of the few business mavens who can still claim widespread popularity after a highly-publicized scandal. She is the founder and former CEO of Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc., a company with interests in publishing, television, merchandising, electronic commerce, and related international partnerships. In the early 2000s, America’s most famous homemaker became the center of headlines, speculations, and eventually a federal investigation concerning her stock trading. Martha Stewart was accused of insider trading after she sold four thousand ImClone shares one day before that firm’s stock price plummeted. Although the charges of securities fraud were thrown out, Ms. Stewart was found guilty of four counts of obstruction of justice and lying to investigators. She was sentenced to five months of prison, five months of house arrest, and two years of probation. After her release from prison, Martha Stewart involved herself in a variety of ventures, including magazines, a short-lived reality television show “The Apprentice: Martha Stewart,” “The Martha Stewart Show,” and branded items sold by flower shops, KB Homes, and Macy’s. Martha Stewart still controls much of Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia. Even though she was barred from acting as director of the company for five years, Stewart continues to control about 50 percent of Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc. stock and about 90 percent of voting stock. While it often takes many years for businesspeople to regain trust after corporate misconduct, Martha Stewart remains a beloved household icon for thousands of loyal fans. EVOLUTION OF A MEDIA EMPIRE Martha Stewart’s lucrative career includes stockbroker, caterer, business owner, and home living expert. Born in 1941 as Martha Kostyra, Stewart developed a passion for cooking,...



Answered Same DayDec 21, 2021

Answer To: What role has Martha Stewart’s image played in the insider trading scandal? 2. Will Martha Stewart...

Robert answered on Dec 21 2021
135 Votes
Introduction
The paper analyzes the “Martha Stewart’s Insider Trading Scandal” case study. It attempts to pen
down the circumstances of the events with a view to understand the unethical behavior behind
insider trading. Insider trading is considered harmful because if one person trades with non
public
information, he or she gains an advantage that is impossible for the rest of the public. This is not
only unfair but disruptive to a properly functioning market (Moore, 2007). It may deter investors
from participating in the market at all, undermining the basic purpose of markets, which is to
allow companies to raise capital. Insider trading should not be banned if it assists in moving a
stock price to a new equilibrium quickly, so that non-insiders are trading at appropriate prices
sooner. In short, overall economic efficiency is reduced. It’s in the public interest. Since 2002
Martha Stewart was investigated by the SEC and the FBI for Inside Trading but it is interesting
that she wasn’t found guilty or accused on any of those charges; she was charge for conspiracy,
obstruction of justice and false statement (Carroll 2009). It was her un-ethical behavior what
drove her into innumerable allegations and public embarrassments.
Analysis
Q1: What role has Martha Stewart’s image played in the insider trading scandal?
Martha Stewart was guilty on four counts: obstruction of justice, conspiracy, and two counts of
making false statements. Judge Miriam Goldman Cedarbaum sentenced Stewart under the
federal sentencing guidelines. Martha Stewart, chief executive officer of Stewart Living
Omnimedia, Inc., became a suspect of insider trading when she sold 4,000 shares of her ImClone
stock the day before the Food and Drug Administration made a public announcement that it
would not accept an approval application for Erbitux, a new cancer drug, developed by ImClone
(Moohr 2007).
Going back several years in Stewart’s life, one notices that she is a daughter of Polish
immigrants. She worked as a stock broker in her earlier career. Whether Stewart’s decision to
sell ImClone stocks was either an impulse decision or a calculated move to cut losses will be
difficult to determine. Everyone makes mistakes in life but we avoid making blunders.
Sometimes personal success, wealth, and ego make a person feel that he or she is invincible.
Even though she was a multimillionaire, greed compelled her to commit an illegal act (Carroll
2009).
Stewart has a very positive mindset. She is more of a leader than a manager. She believed that
MSLO will prosper in the near future (Moohr 2007). She had courage to overcome challenging
circumstances. Stewart had faith in her heart that success is not too far if she sticks with core
business values and maintains the quality of MSLO’s products.
Ms. Stewart received insider information from her broker that her close friend, Dr. Sam Waksal,
chief executive officer of ImClone was attempting...
SOLUTION.PDF

Answer To This Question Is Available To Download

Related Questions & Answers

More Questions »

Submit New Assignment

Copy and Paste Your Assignment Here