Element
|
Basic
(1-4 points)
|
Sufficient
(5-8 points)
|
Accomplished
(9-12 points)
|
Two Quotations
|
Quotations are missing, incomplete, or incorrectly cited.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Quotations are complete but are insignificant.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Quotations are complete and significant.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Two Personal Statements
|
Statements are missing, incomplete, or contain a summary of book.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Personal statements are complete, but superficial.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Personal statements are insightful and strongly connected to the book.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Three Questions
|
Questions are missing or incomplete.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Questions are complete but superficial.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Questions are meaningful and show a depth of thought.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Three Answers
|
Answers are missing, incomplete, not matched to questions, incomplete sentences.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Answers are complete, but are not all matched well to the questions and/or are superficial.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Answers are complete, meaningful, and show depth of thought.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Summary
|
Summary is missing, incomplete, or are incomplete sentences.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Summary is complete, but it does not address B-M-E and the plot.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Summary is complete, meaningful, and show depth of plot and thought.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Theme & Topic
|
Theme and topic are missing, incomplete, or are incomplete sentences.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Theme and topic is complete, but is superficial.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Theme and topic are complete, and show the depth of thought.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Two Images
|
Images are missing, partially missing.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Images are complete but do not represent the book well.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Images are complete, represent the book well, and look nice.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Color Codes & Key
|
Color coding and/or key are missing.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Color coding and key are complete but with some minor inaccuracies.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Color coding and key are complete and accurate.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Usage & Mechanics
|
Spelling, punctuation, and/or other usage errors throughout page.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
Mostly correct with some errors in spelling, punctuation, and/or other usage issues.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
Very few, if any, errors in spelling, punctuation, and/or usage issues.
9----------10----------11----------12
|
Overall Impression & Aesthetics
|
One-pager looks messy, with no evidence of prior planning or thought.
1----------2----------3----------4
|
One-pager looks moderately neat and well planned.
5----------6----------7----------8
|
One-pager is aesthetically pleasing, neat, well organized, with evidence of prior planning or thought.
9----------10----------11----------12
|