What are some basic diff erences between viewing a photograph of a real man being killed and a painting of such an event? Does that distinction alone qualify or disqualify either work as a work of...

What are some basic diff erences between viewing a photograph of a real man being killed and a painting of such an event? Does that distinction alone qualify or disqualify either work as a work of art?

To what extent does Carter’s photograph have artistic form? Are there as many meaningless details in the Carter as in the Adams?