This term paper assignment involves the issue of the government "taking" of private land which we will deal with in more detail when we get to Chapter 17. As always, if you have any questions or comments, please do not hesitate to contact me.
"No man's life, liberty or property are safe while the legislature is in session"
-- Judge Gideon Tucker
FACT SITUATION:Johnny Appleseed owns a 356 acre fruit orchard with scenic river frontage along the Floodsalot River which he purchased in 1976. Early in the 1930s, the state government received money from the federal government to be used on projects that would stimulate the economy and create jobs. Starting in 1934, the state began to erect a dam 4 miles upstream from what would becomeJohnny’s property. The dam was completed in 1939 and provided electricity, water for drinking, flood control and recreational activities on the reservoir.
In 1996, the state experienced an unusually rainy winter and that spring, after almost 60 years of reliability, the dam began to show evidence of stress and leaks began to appear. Engineers conducted an emergency inspection of the dam and concluded that water must be released quickly or the valley below might run the risk of a catastrophic flood.
Acknowledging that releasing water in the manner recommended would cause some limited flooding, the agency responsible for operating the dam released the water.
Sadly, Johnny’s fruit orchard was flooded and, as a result, he lost his crop for that year. In addition, many of the fruit trees in his orchard were damaged beyond repair and Johnny was faced with the expensive prospect of replacing these trees and waiting several years for the trees to mature enough to bear fruit.
ASSIGNMENT:Assuming that there has been a “taking” as defined in your textbook, was this a taking under the state’s right of eminent domain (therefore requiring due process and compensation) or a taking under the state’s police powers (therefore no compensation is required)? You decide which taking applies in this case and write a paper defending your decision and how pertinent and relevant your authority is for supporting your position.
There is no “right”” or “wrong” position on this issue and you will not be graded down for having selected the “wrong” position. Your grade will be based solely on how forceful and convincing your argument is (including your citations of authority) in support of your position. You should be aware of two hard and fast rules I follow:
- Wikipedia by itself is not a satisfactory source for information. You can start with Wikipedia if you wish, but your citations of authority need to come from other sources.
- Plagiarism is one of the seven deadly academic sins, in my opinion. If your information is not first hand knowledge, I require citations for your sources and quotation marks if you use someone else’s words
The body of the paper is to be no longer than six pages (for undergraduate students) and at least 6 pages, but no longer than 10 pages (for graduate students), exclusive of title page and bibliography.
To ease your mind, we have not touched on this subject yet so there is still a lot to learn about "takings" which we will consider in Chapter 17 in late March.
As stated in the syllabus, the term paper is due at 11:59 PM, Sunday, April 17th.