The attached article relates to fundamental questions that go to the nature of property, the significance of possession, pluralistic understandings of ‘ownership’ and relationships to land, and the contested nature of propertied claims to land and space.
Describe
means ‘to give a detailed account’ of the article, a ‘report’ or ‘recounting’ of what the work says. In other words, you are required to descriptively outline the article in question.
Analyse
means ‘to examine methodically and in detail, typically in order to explain or interpret it.’ In the case of the journal article you select, you are required to interpret and explore the author’s central argument(s).
Critique
means ‘to evaluate a theory in a detailed and analytical way’. In the case of the journal article you select, you are required to reflect on what the article says, and how it relates conceptually (and hence more broadly) to wider questions of law, property and society.
In critiquing the article, you must draw parallels, or make linkages or connections with the other two (2) journal articles.
Legal scholars need to develop and acquire disciplinary specific skills of
reading
legal works,
writing
legal papers, and
thinking
legally. This assessment item therefore requires that you
read
all
three (3) journal articles,
that you
write
and engage in a description and analysis of the selected journal article, and lastly, that you engage in higher order
thinking
by critiquing what the journal article means in terms of its connections to the other two articles, and more generally in terms of its implications for the role of property in law and society.