Critical reasoning, presentation and defence of an argument and/or position
•
Critical analysis of the driving forces (economic, social, political, institutional, developmental) behind the environmental determinants; the impact of the environmental risk on the geographic population; and equity issues associated with the environmental risk(30%)
|
Specific position (perspective or argument) fails to take into account the complexities of the issue(s) or scope of the assignment.
Makes assertions that are not justified.
|
Specific position (perspective or argument) begins to take into account the issue(s) or scope of the assignment.
Justifies any conclusions reached with arguments not merely assertion.
|
Specific position (perspective or argument) takes into account the complexities of the issue(s) or scope of theassignment. Others’points of view are acknowledged.
Justifies any conclusions reached with well-formed arguments not merely assertion.
|
Specific position (perspective or argument) is expertly presented and accurately takes into account the complexities of the issue(s) and scope of the assignment.
Justifies any conclusions reached with well-developed arguments.
|
Specific position (perspective or argument) is presented expertly, authoritatively and imaginatively, accurately taking into account the complexities of the issue(s) and scope of the assignment. Limits of position are acknowledged.
Justifies any conclusions reached with sophisticated arguments.
|
Analysis and application with synthesis of new knowledge
•Understanding of current policies, regulation, and management of the issue, and use of evidence to make recommendations for improvements (25%)
|
Limited synthesis and analysis.
Limited application/recommendat ions based upon analysis.
|
Demonstrated analysis and synthesis of new knowledge with application.
Shows the ability to interpret relevant information and literature.
|
Well-developed analysis and synthesis with application of recommendationslinked to analysis/synthesis.
|
Thoroughly developed and creative analysis and synthesis with application of pretested models and/ or independently developed models and justified recommendations linked to analysis/synthesis.
|
Highly sophisticated and creative analysis, synthesis of new with existing knowledge.
Strong application by way of pretested models and / or independently developed models. Recommendations
|