Need a 3 page reaction paper to Cosmic Race by Jose Vasconcelos (I have attached it)
38 The Cosmic Race jOSE VASCONCELOS* In Mexico, a confluence of armed revolts succeeded in toppling the prolonged auto- cratic presidency of Porfirio Diaz who fled the country in 1911. Compdsing a series of violent upsurges in the battle for political power, the Mexican Refolution lasted more than a decade thereafter. During those turbulent years, cultGral philosopher Jose Vasconcelos (1882-1959) had campaigned for Francisco Madero, the demo- cratically elected head of state, assassinated within two years of his term during a 1913 coup d1etat staged by General Victoriano Huerta. Vasconcelos was forced to seek exile in France and, later at odds with Venustiano Carranza's presidency, sought refuge in the United States. Eventually in 1920, under the presidency of General Alvaro Obregon, the nation was now prepared to begin a material, ideological, and cultural reconstruction. Vasconcelos had returned to Mexico as rector ofthe National University of Mexico, and later as Minister of Public Education (1921-4). In that capacity, he gathered artists and intellectuals to contribute to the emerging revolu- tionary culture: a progressive agenda aimed to provide social welfare, widespread literacy, and art for the people. The muralist movement in Mexican art flourished thanks to the support of Vasconcelos who commissioned painters to cover walls of public buildings with nationalist content. Jose Vasconcelos and the muralist painters sought to reverse the aesthetic and intellectual dependency of Mexico on foreign models by firmly grounding art and culture in native tradition. Indigenismo, that is, a renewed attention to Mexico's ancient civilizations and indigenous culture, linked art to the nation-building project, * Jose Vasconcelos (1997 [1925]) The Cosmic Race (trans. Didier T. Jaen, pp. 7-40). Baltimore, MD: The johns Hopkins University Press. Modern Art in Africa, Asia, and Latin America: An Introduction to Global Modernisms, First Edition. Edited by Elaine O'Brien, Everlyn Nicodemus, Melissa Chiu, Benjamin Genocchio, Mary K. Coffey, and Roberto Tejada. © 2013 Blackwell Publishing Ltd. Published 2013 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd. The Cosmic Race 403 even as indigenous subjects could be portrayed emptied of active historical participa- tion and meaning. Mexico was forging an image of itself by foregrounding the value. of its Indian ethnicity1 its ancient ruins, its manual arts, the country's long history and volcanic landscape, and with mythologies old and new. Vasconcelos published La raza c6smica [The Cosmic Race] in 1925. It is a dense piece of rhetoric filled with internal contradictions and ambivalent motives. Just as science fiction is ot~rwise known as speculative literature, one might consider The Cosmic Race a speculatil(~ ethnography. Its argument is with Anglo-European and US American "exceptionalism/' even as it makes special claims of its own. Vasconcelos sought to refute those attitudes that considered the Iberian Americas as some sort of" lesser new world." To this end, he found recourse in the ancient civili- zations of Mesoamerica and the Andes, along with that unique phenomenon result- ing from the conquest's foundational violence: namely, mestizaje, the sweeping integration .over ,time of peoples and cultures from Europe (above all Spain and Portugal) with native peoples of Indo-America. A diagnostic and a philosophy of the future, The Cosmic Race submits mestizaje as "the moral and material basis for the union· of all men into a fifth universal race, the fruit of all the previous ones and ame- lioration ofeverything past." The Cosmic Race may strike readers today as alarmingly racialist or utterly • outlandish. Itis important to recall the unifying nationalist goals of Mexico's new state formation at the time this was written, as well as the audience to which the essay was directed - namely, the cultural elites of "Our America" (see Roberto Fer·nandez Retamar on Jose Marti, this volume). Vasconcelos opposes the notion that there can be anything resembling an impartial empirical history. Instead, he offers what Fernandez Retamar refers to as a "vast col}lprehensive theory" grounded in ex[ierimental intuition. For Vasconcelos, Europe's expansionist project had served as "a bridge" uniting the "four racial trunks: the Black, the Indian, the Mongol, and the White." An overarching cultural difference remained between the dominant colonizers of the modern period, Spain and England, but more precisely, between "Latinism" and "AnglocSaxonism." As a child, Vasconcelos had grown up on the US-Mexico border and attended school in Eagle Pass, Texas. Having experi- enced the United States first hand, he would claim that, "ideologically, the Anglos continue to conquer us." In a 1932 issue of a US journal Vasconcelos later came to his own defense against those who depicted him as an "anti-foreigner" or as "a racial patriot overzealous for the interests of Mexico and Spanish America." He did not object to the United States, he clarified; he opposed its "political influence in Mexico because it has always been exercised for the benefit of the big business interests, and for the behoof o( a few Mexican traitors whose conduct is that of despots and military dictators." Despite the prevailing indigenismo of Mexico's cultural renaissance, Vasconcelos did not disavow the cultural heritage of Spain. On the contrary he values the Spanish over the Anglo-Saxon precisely because of the former's capacity to assimilate "a mixture of dissimilar races." He writes: "Spanish colonization created mixed races [whereas] the English kept on mixing only with the whites and annihilated the natives." It is in Iberian America whence there will emerge a f i' 404 jose Vasconcelos future ~as remote as Atlantis stands in relation to the pa~t- for "the definitive race, the synthetical race, the integral race, made up of the:genius and the blood of all peoples and, for that reason, more capable of true, brotherhood and of a truly universal vision." A racial thinke~ Vasconcelos was not exempt from his own,period-based racism, especially with regard to peoples of African and Asian descent. The ,Cosmic Race, howeve~ was not meant as a prescriptive text submitting a form of eugenics. It was not a plan for improving the human species: Rather, itproposes an ethics that views complexity as an aesthetic value, and benevolence capable of producing a more dig- nified humanity: "Procreation by love is already a good antecedent for a healthy progeny, but it is necessary that love itself be a work of art, and not the last resort of desperate people.'' Equally important ,as his, writings are those works he commissioned from Jose Clemente Orozco, David Alfaro Siqueiros1and Diego Rivera. The latter's murals at the National Palace are discussed by Leonard Forgaraitin this volume. Rivera also produced an ambitious series of narrative murals ih the Palace of Public Education in Mexico City. There, Vasconcelos had allegories carved to rep- resent "Spain, Mexico, Greece, and India [Africa and the rest of Asia are glaring omissions], the four particular civilizations that have most to contribute to the formation of Latin America." Consider Leonard Folgarait's analysis of Diego Rivera's murals at Mexico, City's National Palace. What were the pitfalls of mestizaje as ,employed in the ideological service of Mexico's revolutionary regime? Who does this vision exclude? How does Vasconcelos's biological model of utopian advancement account for the place of women or that of alternate sexua'lities? Does Vasconcelos argue for the eventual disappearance of racial difference? Or does he rehearse compelling language to cast doubt altogether on the term "race" as a methodically quantifiable category? How is mestizaje in The Cosmic Race ofl925 comparable to the Brazilian metaphor of consumption in Oswald de Andrade's 1928 "Cannibalist Manifesto"? How are these two essays a response to the racial beliefs associated with Eurocentrism? Compare Vasconcelos's racialism with com- mentary by Frantz Fanon, Aime Cesaire, and ,Qusmane Sembene in the African modernism section. Further Readings Brenne~ Anita Cl943) The Wind That Swept Mexico: The History ofthe Mexican Revolution, 1910-1942. New York, NY: Harper & Brothers. Brenner, Anita (2002Cl929J) Idols Behind Altars: Modern Mexican Art ahd Its Cultural Roots. New York, NY: Dover Publications. Hedrick, Tace, (2003) Mestizo Modernism: Race, Nation, and Identity in Latin American Culture, 1900-1940. New Brunswick, NY: 'Rutgers University Press: Knight, Alan Cl990l"Racism, Revolution, and Indigenismo: Mexico, 1910-1940." In Richard Graham (ed.l, The Idea of Race in Latin America, 1870-1940 (pp. 71-113). Austin,TX: University of Texas Press. Vasconcelos, Jose Cl932) "Why I Became a Magazine Editor." Books Abroad 6Cll: 6-9. The Cosmic Race 405 Mestizaje I In the opinion of respectable geologists, the American continent includes some of the most ancient regions of the world. The Andes are, undoubtedly, as. old as any other mountainrange on earth. And while the land itself is ancient, the traces of life and human culture also go back in time beyond any calculations. The architec- tural ruins of legendary Mayans, Quechuas, and Toltecs are testimony of civilized life previous to the oldest foundations of towns in the Orient and Europe. [ ... ] If we are, then, geologically ancient, as .well as in respect to the tradition, how can we still continue to accept the fiction, invented by our European fathers, of the novelty of a continent that existed before the appearance of the land from where the discoverers and conquerors came? The question has paramount importance to those who insist in looking· for a plan in History. [ ... ] Greece laid the foundations of Western or European civilization; the white civilization that, upon expanding, reached the forgotten shores of the American continent in order to consummate the task of re-civilization and re-population. Thus we have the four stages and the four racial trunks: the Black, the Indian, the Mongol, and the White. The latter, after organizing itself in Europe, has become the invader of the world, and has considered itself destined to rule, as did each of the previous races during their time of power. It is clear that domination by the whites will also be temporary, but their mission is to serve as a bridge. The white race has brought the world to a state in which all human types and cultures will be.able to fuse with each other. The civilization developed and organized in our times by the