IBM 301Spring 2016 Paper Grading GuidelinesRemember, the assignment is to present a 3-4 page critique of any Harvard Business Review of MIT SloanManagement review published since 2014. Points will be...

IBM 301Spring 2016 Paper Grading GuidelinesRemember, the assignment is to present a 3-4 page critique of any Harvard Business Review of MIT SloanManagement review published since 2014. Points will be assigned as follows:4 points – Your use the following organization for your essay:Paragraph 1 – You introduce the main idea of the article and your main point of disagreement. Brieflyintroduce your three main sub-points.Paragraph 2 – Explain the idea of the article in a bit more detail (but still be brief, remember the point ofthe assignment is to critique the article, not to summarize. So you need to write just enough so thatyour reader gets the gist of what the article is about).Paragraphs 3,4, and 5 – Your three supporting sub-points. Make sure each the gist of each sub-point isclearly stated in the first sentence of each of these paragraphs.Paragraph 6 – Briefly present some alternative viewpoint- even though you’re critiquing the article, doesit still hold some value?Paragraph 7 – Concluding paragraph. Reiterate your main point and why you think it’s important.6 points–Your three supporting sub-points all make sense, are well-sourced, and logically build to yourmain point. I can clearly tell what your sub-points are and how they relate to one another.4 points – Writing is concise, clear, and free of fluff (see the “How to Organize Any Essay” guide sectionon common sources of fluff).4 points – Citations are used where appropriate(seehttps://www.princeton.edu/pr/pub/integrity/pages/cite/ as a rough guide, ask me if you’re unsure). UseMLA or APA format. This is especially important when explaining the logic behind your thesis.2 points – Reference section is properly formatted, and I can easily look up your sources if I tried (shouldbe easy points to get).Again, use MLA or APA format. The reference page does not count towards thepage limit.NOTE: I will also deduct points for improper formatting (e.g. using different fonts, inconsistent marginsor spacing, etc.).