1. Is there ambiguity in the phrase “cost all you guys your jobs . . . and that’s why we have to put a stop to it”? Would the ambiguity be more evident had Randall not recently lost his job? Clue:...

1. Is there ambiguity in the phrase “cost all you guys your jobs . . . and that’s why we have to put a stop to it”? Would the ambiguity be more evident had Randall not recently lost his job? Clue: Look at the first sentence below Section A of the court’s decision.

2. Why is the court unwilling to consider the question of whether Hildreth’s statements were a protected expression of opinion? Clue: Take a look at the rationale in Section B.