files attached

1 answer below »
files attached


1 B.A Law-Tort 2022/23 Autumn Repeat Assessment This accounts for 30% of the overall marks for this module Short Essay- 2,500 Words Maximum (excluding References) This is a piece of research-based, analytical written work. Topic A “compensation culture” has developed in Ireland as a result of over-zealous use of the law of negligence. In the Court of Appeal case of O’Flynn v Cherry Hill Inns Limited Trading as The Oliver Plunkett Bar [2017] IECA 211, Irvine J. made several comments in relation to individual responsibility, which seem to reflect the current opinion of the Court of Appeals: “Adult members of society are obliged to take care for their own safety and cannot divest themselves of responsibility for their actions”. The Court of Appeals appears to be adopting a more reserved approach to personal injury claims, though it remains to be seen whether or not this focus on individual responsibility will continue. Critically discuss this statement and the impact of the O’Flynn v Cherry Hill Inns judgment. Submission Date – 1st September 2023 at 23.59 Through Turnitin Students must ensure that the essay is correctly referenced following Department guidelines and that a Bibliography/ Reference list is included. All source material used within the essay should be acknowledged in the essay text (citation) and also in the references section (full details of the source). Failure to acknowledge sources is plagiarism. All facts and ideas taken from sources (textbooks, articles and internet sites etc.) must be acknowledged by referencing. Where the exact words of a source are used this is identified by use of quotation marks. Plagiarism includes the representation of the work of any other person, from any source whatsoever, as one’s own. This includes the verbatim copying of another’s work, the close paraphrasing of another’s work and the deliberate presentation of another’s concept as one’s own. All of this can be avoided by acknowledging your sources through appropriate use of referencing. Collusion is also prohibited unless expressly authorised. This is the conscious collaboration between two or more students in the production of work which is ultimately submitted by each in an identical or substantially similar form and/ or is represented by each as the product of his/ her own individual efforts. IF IN DOUBT ASK! It is better to submit nothing than commit plagiarism/ collusion/cheating as this may affect your academic record and chosen career! 2 Assessment Criteria The essay should:- • Identify and discuss the relevant legal concepts. • Identify and coherently examine any relevant policy issues. • Draw reasoned conclusions which are supported by argument and legal authority (use caselaw!) • Produce an accurate and up-to-date picture of the law in this area. • Use appropriate terminology and language for a formal essay. • Show an ability to present an analytical argument in a comprehensible manner. Other Important Considerations • Do not over-use the facts of decided cases • Use judicial quotes but do not over-quote. Keep them short and punchy. • Your work should show critical analysis rather than be merely descriptive. • There should be evidence of research beyond what is covered in lectures. • There should be numerous references whereby you cite authorities. • Use the Oscala/ Footnotes system correctly and consistently. • You should use the classic essay style of an innovative and coherent introduction, main body of discussion and authoritative summary or conclusion. • You should take great care with the language, grammar, syntax and clarity of your essay. High marks will only be awarded where the essay shows an authority of style and precision of language. • Avoid just writing all you know. Questions rarely require this! Tailor your essay to what the question is asking you to do. • Only talk about a specific element of the law if you can make it relevant to answering the question. • Keep to the word limit. • Submit your essay in on time! Late submission will result in loss of marks. Late submissions penalties: The total marks available for an unauthorised late submission of assessment will be reduced by the following: o 15% for work up to one week late. o 30% for work up to two weeks late. o More than two weeks late will receive a mark of zero. 3
Answered 8 days AfterAug 23, 2023

Answer To: files attached

Sanjukta answered on Sep 01 2023
37 Votes
5
LAW
Introduction
It has been observed that in the case namely O’Flynn v Cherry Hill Inns Limited Trading the judge of the High Court Concluded that in setting the closing speed for the automatic door t other than the lowest speed as it was possible the appellant has failed in their duty for protecting the consumers like Ms O'Flynn from the injury that was foreseeable. The appellant seemed to be seeking for appealing against the reward of the general damages.
Main Body
The compensation culture has developed a lot in Ireland. One of the most frequently
complained aspects in terms of the alleged compensation culture in this country and the damages that are charged happens to be extremely high, specifically when contrasted with other countries damages that are awarded for the soft-tissue injuries in Ireland are mainly 5 times those awarded for the same injuries in the UK. In the recent times, the Court of Appeals has basically adopted a pro-individual responsibility kind of attitude which will be helping to lower the damages that is awarded, via the present examples like Luas-Surfing Settlement mainly highlighted that the public at large along with the private firms are still worried in terms of the heavy damages[footnoteRef:1]. [1: Binchy W. Tort Law in Ireland: A Half-Century Review. THE IRISH JURIST. 2016 Jan 1:199-218]
From the point of view of the legal concept it can be said that the compensation culture is basically a term that is used for implying that within a society, a lot of claims for torts for compensation remains unjustified or fraudulent also and the people who are seeking compensation needs to be criticised thoroughly. Therefore, the culture of compensation can also be looked upon as a sociological phenomenon and it need not to be mirrored in legal statistics and rules.
It has been stated by some of the scholars that the Tort Law is the main element for encouraging the compensation culture. These scholars have suggested that a lot of institutions who are cancelling the activities mainly because of the out of fear claims were doing so for simple financial reasons and using a litigation problem as a smokescreen. The authors have also highlighted that the claims that is under the tort were going down at the time when the bill was introduced. Furthermore, even it was said that so prevalent was the media hysteria that concerns the compensation culture that the government wanted to nip in the bud any suggestion that such a culture was developing[footnoteRef:2]. On the contrary, the compensation culture from the legal perspective can be also regarded as an ethos, the fundamentals of which are that the adversities in general, short demonstration of God are presumably another person's shortcoming and the experiencing should be feeling significantly better or at any rate that is set apart by the receipt of cash. There are some of the things that tend to constitute the culture of Tort. The following are some of the major factors that constitute the compensation culture Jury grants: in the US the jury settles on choices on realities, and concludes the size of the honours in private injury cases. This doesn't really occur in the UK, where judges will hear and conclude individual injury cases, furthermore, measure harms. Reformatory harms: juries in the US can make grants above and past that which is expected to repay the inquirer completely, by granting additional harms to rebuff the respondent. This is frequently the clarification for extravagant honours in the States. Lawful expenses: in the UK the terrible party is expected to pay the expenses of the fruitful party. This goes about as a hindrance against bringing misleading cases, furthermore, a motivating force to shield such cases. No such rule exists in the US[footnoteRef:3]. [2: Cane P, Atiyah PS. Atiyah's accidents, compensation and the law. Cambridge University Press; 2013 Feb 28] [3: Farrow A. Workplace-focused health promotion programs in the United Kingdom and Ireland. North Carolina Medical Journal. 2006 Nov 1;67(6):458-62.
]
Media cannot escape the eyes of law as they are the major culprit for fuelling the compensation perception culture. Moreover, there are a lot of articles that gave the impression in terms of the highest pay-outs that are available if the claimants tend to sue in the tort. These types of stories will report the result of the notorious cases they report, or even acknowledge the cases the cases from various jurisdictions are quite unlikely for succeeding in the UK because of the various legal rules. There is a report that is commissioned by the Department of Constitutional Affairs that has found out the 4/5ths of the people who are surveyed the believe that there is a culture in the United Kingdom of people making the claims of the false for the personal injuries. On the other hand, the compensation culture has featured more or less in the popular press over the last decade. There have, nonetheless, been relatively barely any scholarly investigations and such examinations as there have been have generally cantered around private injury claims[footnoteRef:4]. A pay culture, in the event that it exists, could broaden a lot more extensive than that. This article analyses the outstanding expansion in the utilization of the term 'pay culture' in the public printed media starting around 1995 with accessible measurements connecting with the Sovereign's Seat, Region Courts, and business councils. A long way from spiralling upwards, these insights show an expansive downfall across a scope of cases except for claims before the work councils, where...
SOLUTION.PDF

Answer To This Question Is Available To Download

Related Questions & Answers

More Questions »

Submit New Assignment

Copy and Paste Your Assignment Here